Q: I just used an online BMI calculator and it said I was overweight!  Should I be worried?

A:  The BMI–or Body Mass Index– is one of many measurements that clinicians use to evaluate your overall risk for chronic diseases like diabetes, hypertension and heart disease.   It is a calculation that takes into account the ratio of your weight to your height, which at the population level has been shown to correlate to disease risk.

  • A BMI over 25 is considered to be ‘overweight’–meaning that there is shown to be an elevated risk of disease in groups of people at that BMI level.
  • A BMI over 30 is considered to be obese, and suggests another cutoff point at which an even higher risk of disease is observed.
  • Interestingly, health risk also increases at very low BMIs: a BMI less than 18.5 is considered underweight and is undesirable as well.
  • BMIs between 18.5 and 24.9 are considered to be “normal,” meaning that there is no increased risk of health issues associated with people in that category.

However, at the individual level, BMI alone is not predictive of whether a certain person is at increased risk for disease, because there are a lot of factors that influence the calculation itself–as well as factors that influence disease beyond weight–which make BMI an imperfect indicator of an individual’s health risk on its own.

For example:

  • BMI does not account for body composition, only total body weight.  If you’re an athlete or weightlifter carrying around a lot of muscle, your BMI may suggest you’re overweight, but given your high percentage of lean mass and low percentage of body fat, you would not be considered at increased risk for disease based on your BMI.
  • Weight is just one factor that contributes to disease risk; cardiovascular fitness level counts for a lot, too.  Research has shown that fit people who are considered obese based on their BMIs still have significantly lower risk of disease and death than unfit people with “normal” BMIs.  In other words, improving one’s cardiovascular fitness level through exercise at all BMI levels has real and important health benefits, regardless of whether the exercise produces weight loss.

For these reasons, BMI is but one of several metrics we use to determine someone’s individual risk for disease, and should only be considered in the context of factors such as race, fitness level, waist circumference, family history of disease, smoking status and clinical test results like cholesterol levels and blood pressure.  If you’re concerned about whether your individual BMI places you at risk for disease down the road, make an appointment with your doctor to discuss whether weight loss would benefit you; and rest assured that if you are overweight, even a modest weight loss of 5-10% of total body weight is associated with significant improvements in health risk and chronic disease symptoms.

Sincerely
Tamara Duker Freuman

http://www.tamaraduker.com/

Comments

  1. [...] certain foods you feel to be health-compromising,  if you are unable to maintain a minimally healthy body weight or a healthy relationship with food and eating because of your food restrictions, then it may be [...]

  2. [...] adjusted the results to account for possible confounding factors such as smoking status, BMI, alcohol intake, physical activity and fiber intake.  This finding appears to be consistent with a [...]

  3. [...] absorb more calcium than heavier individuals, the researchers tested to see if body mass index (BMI, a calculation to determine body fat based on height and weight) made a difference. Indeed it did. [...]

  4. [...] four years.  The researchers compared the children by vitamin D status, and factored in their age, BMI, family income, and severity of their asthma.  What they found was that hospitalization for asthma [...]

  5. [...] to:exercise lesshave fathers with higher education levels and live with both parentshave a higher body mass index (BMI; kg/m2)have a lower intake of fish, EPA, and DHADue to the nature of the study design, [...]

  6. [...] at protecting against cardiovascular disease than taking a B-vitamin supplement:Maintain a healthy weightEat a heart-healthy diet rich in folate (whole grains, beans, asparagus, beets, dark leafy greens, [...]

  7. [...] finding is that the subjects who had a greater intake of animal protein also had a higher BMI, were more likely to be smokers, and had lower intakes of fruits and vegetables. Not only were [...]

  8. [...] looked at 240 teens between 16 and 19 years-old. Of these teens, 18% were obese, but the average BMI was 23.1, which is considered normal weight.  Continuing with their normal lifestyle, teens wore [...]

  9. [...] or obese.  In spite of their weight loss, most participants remained overweight, averaging a BMI of [...]

  10. [...] disease, and some cancers. To determine your BMI, you can use this calculator and read our previous article on what that BMI really [...]

  11. [...] disease, and some cancers. To determine your BMI, you can use this calculator and read our previous article on what that BMI really [...]

  12. [...] a second pregnancy. Women were placed into a category depending on whether their body mass index (BMI, an indicator of weight for height) increased, decreased or remained the same at their second [...]

  13. [...] that regardless of race or ethnic group, two to four years later there was no effect on the BMI of those kids.  As a result, policies should be more focused on changing the environment that our [...]

About Tamara Duker Freuman, MS, RD, CDN

Tamara Duker Freuman is a Registered Dietitian (RD) and New York State Certified Dietitian-Nutritionist (CDN) who holds a Master’s Degree in Clinical Nutrition from New York University. She completed her clinical training at New York University in affiliation with Mount Sinai Medical Center in New York City, and currently offers medical nutrition therapy and nutrition counseling services to clients in the New York metro area; for information on her nutrition services, visit www.tamaraduker.com/nutrition-services/. Tamara is a member of the American Dietetic Association, the New York State Dietetic Association and the Greater New York Dietetic Association.

Category

Diet, Nutrition, Weight Loss

Tags

, ,